- GIFT
- Talent
- Kind of certificate
- Perfect pitch, e.g.
- It's a ___!
- Special talent
- Present
- Donation
- Thank-you card subject
- Package under the Christmas tree
- Innate talent
- Natural talent
- Mother's Day purchase
- Gab, for some
- Holiday offering
- Decoratively wrapped item
- Stocking stuffer, say
- Inherent ability
- Something for nothing
- It may be under a tree
- Party invitee's purchase
- Horse variety?
- It's usually wrapped
- Party invitee's buy
- Shower offering
- One of a biblical trio
- One often taking a bow
- Traditional 61-Across surprise, aptly boxed, and spelled with the only four letters of the alphabet that don't appear elsewhere in this grid
- Birthday present
- Birthday buy
- __ receipt
- Birthday purchase
- Natural endowment
- Magi offering
- Wedding present
- Natural ability
- Something bestowed
- Birthday present, for example
- Endowment, for instance
- O. Henry's "The ___ of the Magi"
- ESP, e.g.
- Special aptitude.
- Christmas present.
- A special ability.
- Aptitude.
- Bonus.
- Kind of horse
- Xmas offering
- Flair
- Gab, to a deipnosophist
- Gaspar brought one
- With 21 Down, talent for talking
- Kind of wrap
- ESP, they say
- Endowment
- It's not bought
- Partygoer's purchase
- Shower need
- Photographic memory, e.g.
- Easy exam question, so to speak
- Photographic memory or perfect pitch, e.g.
- Gold, frankincense or myrrh, for baby Jesus
- Something that can be wrapped using the starts of 17-, 24-, 40-, 51- and 64-Across
- Anniversary offering
- Stocking stuffer, e.g.
- Shower purchase
- Rare talent
- Special ability
- Birthday party invitee's buy
- It may take a bow
- Something for the birthday girl
- Innate skill
- Wrap it up
- Birthday present, e.g.
- Bottle of wine, say, for a host
- White elephant item
- Type of horse
- Bridal shower offering
- Way to commemorate someone's retirement
- Gold from the Magi, e.g.
- Baby shower offering
- Valentine's Day offering
- Shower sight
- It takes a bow
- One might take a bow
- Shower package
- Boxed mystery
- It may come wrapped in a bow
