- COY
- Affectedly shy
- Homonym of 14-Down
- Playing hard to get
- Quaintly shy
- Playfully innocent
- Simpering
- Not forthcoming
- Demure
- Flirtatious
- Far from forward
- Flirtatiously shy
- Shy
- Hard to pin down
- Affectedly demure
- Quite obviously dissembling
- To His ___ Mistress (17th-century poem)
- Keeping something secret
- Unwilling to lay one's cards on the table
- Hiding something, say
- Playing it close to the vest
- Insincerely modest
- Not exactly wearing one's heart on one's sleeve
- Insincerely noncommittal
- Not giving much away
- Artfully shy
- Bashful
- Like a shrinking violet
- Playfully demure
- Secretive
- Shy, in a flirtatious way
- Reluctant
- Insincerely reluctant to make a decision
- Playfully noncommittal
- Overmodest
- Slyly shy
- Flirtatiously unforthcoming
- Playfully evasive
- Affectedly modest
- Kittenish
- Devious, in a way
- Playfully shy
- Like one saying "Moi?"
- Hardly candid
- Less than forthright
- Reluctant to elucidate
- Modest
- Less than forthcoming
- Slyly hesitant
- Retiring
- Affectedly evasive
- Affectedly secretive
- Reluctant to give details
- Affectively evasive
- Playfully secretive
- Provocatively playful
- Flirty.
- Like Marvell's mistress
- Affectedly devious
- Evasive
- Shrinking modestly
- Arch
- Holding back, in a way
- Not 100% open
- Reserved
- Shy, but maybe not?
- Not exactly outgoing
- Not forthright
- You don't need to be ___, Roy (rhyming Paul Simon lyric)
- Opposite of brazen
- Hardly forward
- Like one saying "Who, little old me?"
- Like a coquette
- Unforthcoming
- Giving evasive answers
- Like the comment "Maybe, maybe not"
- Playfully obtuse, maybe
- Not as shy as one might think
- Coquettishly playful
- Hardly fresh
- Playing hard to get, say
- Artfully evasive
- Not forward
- Feigning shyness
- Like one playing hard to get
- Withholding
- Not sharing much
- Playfully modest
- Slyly reticent
- Far from forthcoming
- Reluctant to commit
- Diffident
- Shy, in a flirty way
- Reluctant to share
- Cutesy
- Shy and sly
- Playfully retiring
- Overly modest
- Overly shy
- Dissembling
- Feigning modesty
- Affectedly innocent
- Flirtatious, in a way
