Crossword clues for It does seem likely:
- BOREDBYRON
- 'She Walks in Beauty' is so dull, it feels like the author barely cared! Seems like it was written by ...
- FLAIRS
- Notations next to usernames, on Reddit (I could clue this like "talents" or "knacks", but that would seem like a weird plural)
- HERMAN
- Cain who seemed like an absurd candidate for president, until other comparative possibilities came into focus
- AVA
- Name whose second letter seems like it "fits" perfectly between its first and third when written in all caps