Crossword clues for I don't believe it! 4 letters:WARYNot readily believingTALEIt's not to be believedBUYSCompletely believesNILEPtolemy believed the Mountains of the Moon was its sourceSHIAThey believe that Ali is the true successor to MuhammadSHAMMake-believeOHNOI can't believe it!ASIFWho's going to believe that?TALLHard to believeFEELBelieveINMEKenny Rogers's "She Believes __"CHERBelieve Grammy winnerEELSAnimals that Aristotle believed were spontaneously generatedLIARHe's not to be believedSAHLWho said "A conservative is someone who believes in reform. But not now"DUDEI can't believe you just did that!ISTSBelieversSTETHard to believe, but they had it right the first timeMETSYa Gotta Believe teamIKIDDon't believe a word of itADIASarah McLachlan single with the lyrics "I do believe I've failed you"ISMSYou'd better believe themHELDBelievedDENYRefuse to believeINMEShe Believes __CHICNile Rodgers band I can't believe aren't in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame yetCAINHerman who said "The more toppings a man has on his pizza, I believe the more manly he is"ISISGoddess believed to be from the Nile DeltaISTSBelievers of some stripeITORBelieve __ Not!CHERBelieve belterISTSBelievers (suffix)OHNOI don't believe thisINEZYou heard the rumors from ___ / You can't believe a word she saysBULLI don't believe you!JONIWhy Don't You Believe In Me? singer ___ JamesSPCAGp. that believes in hiring vetsSWUMTook a dip (I can never believe this is actually a word)OLEOMany of us actually can believe it's not butterXQLAMake believeHAHAI can't believe you fell for thatTRUEBelieve you me!RIDEWith 58-Across, give "Believe" singer a hard time?ALIEIt's not ___ if you believe it (Classic {/Seinfeld/} quote)FIBSThey're hard to believeGASPI can't believe you!ELONAnti-union, Twitter-tantrum-throwing Musk whom I still can't believe Grimes is datingAMENI believe that so much!CHERBelieve singerWHOAThis I can't believe!